Umpire Mask Replacement Pads

Brands: All-Star | Diamond | Force3 | Wilson

Replace your pads every 1 to 2 seasons. The foam inside the pads naturally deteriorates over time and breaks down little-by-little with each impact. Watch the Crew-How-To below for step by step instructions for replacing your mask pads. Learn more in the Umpire Mask Pads Guide.

Sort By

Showing

Of 11

Wilson MLB Wrap Around Umpire Mask Replacement Pads - Black and Grey $79.99	All-Star FM4000MAG Umpire Mask Replacement Pads - Black ABS Plastic Plate in Chin Pad $69.99	Wilson MLB Wrap Around Umpire Mask Replacement Pads - Black $69.99	Force3 Defender Umpire Mask Replacement Pads - Black $59.99
Force3 Defender Umpire Mask Replacement Pads - Tan $59.99	Wilson MLB Umpire Mask Replacement Pads - Tan $49.99 Was ~~$54.99~~ You save $5.00!	Wilson MLB Two Tone Umpire Mask Replacement Pads - Black and Tan $49.99	All-Star LUC Umpire Mask Replacement Pads - Black $39.99
Diamond Quick-Dry Umpire Mask Replacement Pads - Black No Logo. No Free Advertising. $37.99	Wilson Memory Foam Umpire Mask Replacement Pads - Black $34.99 Was ~~$39.99~~ You save $5.00!	Wilson Synthetic Leather Umpire Mask Replacement Pads - Black $29.99

Sort By

Showing

Of 11

Latest Reviews

Wilson MLB Wrap Around Umpire Mask Replacement Pads - Black and Grey

Jeff B., Puyallup, WA

6/25/2025

I am soo glad these wrap around replacements came back! MORE PROTECTION without adding weight. Easy install.

Force3 Defender Umpire Mask Replacement Pads - Black

Darius A., Mount Prospect, IL

6/24/2025

I received my new pads and they fit perfectly. They were very easy to replace. I wish I would’ve swapped them out sooner. I stuck with the old ones for several years and they became so worn down I was no longer comfortable using the mask. I will buy new pads more often from now on.

All-Star FM4000MAG Umpire Mask Replacement Pads - Black

Steve M., Elmhurst, IL

5/26/2025

Replaced my current leather Wilson face mask pads with these all-black All-Star Umpire Mask Replacement Pads and absolutely love them. So much more comfortable and provide a lot more protection from hits to the face. Gives me a lot of confidence to keep my face in "the Slot".